Best 10 Insurance brokers in Lancaster

insurance brokers in Lancaster

They cultivate relationships with a carefully chosen group of well-known regional, national, and global insurers as independent insurance brokers in Lancaster.

These relationships frequently benefit their clients by providing customized commercial, risk management and reduction, employee group benefits, workers’ compensation, property insurance, personal insurance, auto and fleet insurance, and other insurance solutions.


Insurance Brokers in Lancaster

Below is the list of top 10 best Insurance Brokers in Lancaster.

1. Sterling & Brown Brokerage, LLC

Each of their clients is unique to their agency. That is why they are opposed to a “one-size-fits-all” approach to insurance. Sterling & Brown Brokerage, LLC offer personalized solutions to each of their clients and act as advocates if their clients need to file a claim. They can offer the best rate because they have multiple carrier options.

Sterling & Brown Brokerage, LLC value their customers and take pride in consistently providing high-quality service. They present several options for their customers to choose from.

Contact:+1 717-839-0000

Address: 342 N Queen St Rear Warehouse D, Lancaster, PA 17603, United States

2. Bagnall Shaw Insurance

Bagnall Shaw Insurance is a Lancaster, Pennsylvania-based insurance brokerage. They collaborate with some of the industry’s most reputable carriers, offering a wide range of products and services.

Related articles: 10 Top Rated Insurance Brokers in York Pennsylvania

Bagnall Shaw Insurance provides numerous types of insurance. Commercial Auto, Personal Auto, Home, Renters, Builders Risk, Health, Life, Dental, Disability, Commercial Liability, Manufacturing/Industrial, Retail, Business Insurance, Workers Compensation, Umbrellas, Marine, and a variety of other coverages are available.

Their goal is to provide adequate coverage while offering THE BEST pricing available to their clients. Consider having a broker who refuses to accept commissions in order to find their clients the best insurance at the best price.

Contact: +1 717-431-8383

Address: 401 W Orange St, Lancaster, PA 17603, United States

3. Ross Insurance Agency

Ross Insurance Agency’s team of trusted advisors provides the coverage they require at an affordable price to Lancaster PA and surrounding areas.

They are the independent alternative to large national insurance agencies, direct-writers, or captive agents with only one company, working for their clients. With access to over 40 different insurance companies, their insurance agency is here to help clients make the right choices to protect what is most important to them, whether it is personal auto, homeowners, business, life insurance, or disability income.

Contact: +1 717-397-4729

Address: 1496 Lititz Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601, United States

4. Murray

Their story is about assisting people in securing their futures. And it all starts with their past. Paul Murray was a prominent Lancaster County entrepreneur, scientist, and community leader when he founded Murray. He wanted to offer his clients a diverse range of products and services from the start.

He believed in treating people fairly by designing insurance plans that were tailored to the person or project that needed to be protected, even if it meant developing highly technical plans.

The Murray saga continues to this day, As their communities have grown, so have the projects they protect, and the risks and regulations have become more complicated. They have grown and evolved by strategically adding products and experienced professionals, enhancing their ability to create exceptional options and smart, tailored plans.

Murray’s team of more than 200 specialists enables them to conduct in-depth analyses of exposure, safety, business goals, areas for improvement, and opportunities for innovation with each client on an individual basis. Their core solutions, whether as a single service or as comprehensive protection for their clients’ entire business, give clients confidence that they are preparing for their company’s future scalability and sustainable strength.

Contact: +1 717-397-9600

Address: 39 N Duke St, Lancaster, PA 17602, United States

5. Spiziri Insurance Associates

Spiziri Insurance Associates provides personalized service to each of their clients. They understand the importance of working directly with each customer as a family-owned and operated business. They are an independent organization. That is, they work for their clients rather than a single insurance company.

They work with several insurance companies rather than just one. As a result, they can assist their customers in quickly comparing policies and rates. their customers You can rely on them to provide comprehensive solutions for all of their insurance needs.

Spiziri Insurance Associates works for their clients. What does this mean for customers? It means that their customers receive the best possible price as well as personalized service.

Contact: +1 717-299-2515

Address: 226 W Chestnut St, Lancaster, PA 17603, United States

6. EHD Insurance

EHD is one of the largest and most reputable privately held full-service insurance brokers in the United States. They provide a wide range of clients across the country with Employee Benefit Services, Commercial Insurance, Surety, Personal Insurance, Risk Control Services, and the expertise of an in-house claims team.

Their unwavering commitment to the well-being of their clients and colleagues ensures that customers receive exceptional, personalized solutions and care from the start.

Every member of their team is a unified force working for the betterment of their clients and colleagues. They approach insurance and service in a proactive manner, listening to and collaborating with their clients to tailor solutions to their lives and businesses. EHD Insurance works hard to learn and understand their clients’ businesses in order to provide tailored and comprehensive insurance solutions. Consider them a co-pilot in their professional relationship. Clients’ needs come first, and they’re here to keep them on track.

They are real people with insurance knowledge and understanding. As trusted advisors for their clients, regardless of size, they pay attention to the details. EHD Insurance also strives to provide professionalism and integrity at every stage of their clients’ insurance journey.

Contact: +1 717-394-5681

Address: 1857 William Penn Way, Lancaster, PA 17601, United States

7. Gebhard Insurance LLC

Gebhard Insurance LLC has been addressing the unique risks that confront individuals, families, and businesses in Lancaster, PA, and the surrounding Pennsylvania and Maryland areas since 1980. They are confident that by providing their clients with customizable solutions, they can help mitigate these risks and provide a secure future and peace of mind.

As a multigenerational insurance agency, they have assisted in the protection of many families and are now assisting in the protection of their children and so on. Their clients rely on them as their insurance advisor and advocate, which is critical in an emergency.  Gebhard Insurance LLC, they can understand their clients’ need for protection and help form an insurance policy that offers top-notch stability with a quality insurance company that has their clients back by developing a close relationship with them.

Their team consists of knowledgeable, licensed agents with extensive experience. Because each client is unique, they believe in a client-centric approach in which they view each person as an individual with different needs and desires. By delving into their personal exposures, Gebhard Insurance LLC can tailor solutions to best protect them, with the ultimate goal of delivering the best combination of price, coverage, and service.

Contact: +1 717-392-5569

Address: 90 Willow Valley Square, Lancaster, PA 17602, United States

8. Horst Insurance

Horst Insurance has been serving residents and businesses in Pennsylvania’s Southcentral and Southeastern regions for over 100 years. As independent insurance brokers, they can create policies and solutions that protect their clients’ most valuable assets, such as their families, homes, businesses, employees, boats, pets, vehicles, and any other personal or business insurance requirements.

Horst Insurance now employs over 40 insurance agents and professionals who are committed to providing customized insurance programs and value-added services to commercial clients, as well as providing valuable coverage and service options to individuals, couples, and families. They all have the same goal in mind: to become their customers’ trusted insurance advisor.

Horst Insurance is a subsidiary of Horst Group, Inc., a fifth-generation company whose roots date back to the late 1800s, when Joseph Horst built a church in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. Horst Insurance was added in 1981 when Horst acquired Gingrich Stoudt Insurance agency, continuing a legacy established in 1917. Horst Group now has three main business units: construction services, insurance and benefits, and management services.

While Horst Group companies operate in a variety of industries, they are all dedicated to connecting with their customers, understanding their needs, and delivering products and services that they value.

Contact: +1 717-560-1919

Address: 320 Granite Run Dr Suite 201, Lancaster, PA 17601, United States

9. Maranna Insurance

Their insurance industry experience spans more than 100 years, serving Pennsylvania businesses and residents. Liz Martin’s great-grandfather founded the agency by selling homeowners insurance policies to his friends and neighbors and emphasizing personal service.

Four generations later, they continue to provide superior service to each client, locating the best coverage at the best price to meet each client’s personal and business insurance needs. Their philosophy is to treat everyone with the utmost respect, integrity, and courtesy at all times. Their goal is not simply to sell insurance, but to assist clients in better understanding their insurance coverage requirements. They are always happy to answer clients’ insurance questions.

Their services are available whenever clients require them. They are always available to answer their clients’ questions, make process changes, or handle claims quickly.

Contact: +1 717-341-1316

Address: 155 Bender Mill Rd, Lancaster, PA 17603, United States

10. Benefit Design Services Inc

Benefit Design Services, Inc. provides innovative products and services to help customers protect what they work for.

Benefit Design Services, Inc. (BDS) is a recognized leader in the design, implementation, and administration of voluntary benefit programs, with nearly 20 years of experience.

Their track record of professionalism, integrity, and service is reflected in the endorsements of major insurance companies, associations, and marketing organizations.

BDS has strong working relationships with over 20 insurance companies; with such a broad base, they are able to develop and access the widest range of innovative insurance products available. Their clients rely on them to take a diverse product offering and target the exact plans that meet their specific needs.

Contact: +1 717-285-7925

Address: 1200 Corporate Blvd, Lancaster, PA 17601, United States

In Conclusion

Insurance Brokers are now universally recognized as insurance intermediaries who use their skills and expertise to arrange insurance protection in the best interests of their clients, who are the proposers or consumers.


10 Best Insurance brokers in Southampton

10 Top Insurance Brokers in Worcester

Best 10 Insurance brokers in Lancaster

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to top