Top 10 Insurance Brokers in Wisconsin

insurance brokers in Wisconsin

If you are in Wisconsin and need an insurance policy, it is of great importance you seek the services of the insurance brokers in Wisconsin.

Customer peace of mind begins with knowing that their insurance policy truly protects their most valuable assets and ends with knowing that their Insurance Brokers will be there for them with the quickest results when that security is most important.

Customers have options when it comes to Insurance Brokers. One of the benefits of using an Insurance Broker is that they work hard to meet the needs of their clients.


Insurance Brokers in Wisconsin

Below are the top Insurance Brokers in Wisconsin.

  • 1. Behnke Insurance Agencies Inc.

Since 1956, they have been providing the best in personal service at the lowest possible cost. Behnke Insurance, a family-owned agency, was founded on one guiding principle which is to provide the lowest insurance prices without sacrificing the highest commitment to service.

They’ve never wavered in their commitment to building a reputation of professional trust, one long-term relationship at a time, one family, one entrepreneur, one new driver, one new dream.

Related: Insurance brokers in Washington state

Also, they treat their insurance needs as a determined goal, delivering on the promise of tomorrow with sound advice in a changing world, expert care, and consistent results.

They haven’t done their job until the client is safe. Behnke Insurance provides insurance in Fond du Lac, Oshkosh, Waupun, Ripon, Plymouth, and throughout the great state of Wisconsin.

Their agents have assisted countless families, just like current clients, in gaining the peace of mind that comes from knowing that their policy truly protects all of their most valuable assets.

From life insurance to homeowners insurance, business and commercial insurance to auto insurance, their dependable agents have the proven experience to handle all of their clients’ coverage needs while saving them money.

They remain committed to continually improving their clients’ quality of service by using the most advanced technology systems to ensure the quickest processing of client claims and by offering their clients online payment options.

Contact: +1 920-922-3850

Address: 14 Western Ave, Fond du Lac, WI 54935, United States

  1. McClone

McClone’s dedication to making a difference in the community is as important as their dedication to their thirty client partners.

They accomplish this in a variety of ways, including reinvesting 10% of every dollar earned in the communities they serve through their charitable foundation and other corporate gifts.

Employees receive paid time off to volunteer or participate in charitable causes or events, and employee dollar-for-dollar matches of up to $500 per team member are provided for non-profit organizations that are important to them.

They’re a group that works hard to serve their clients and others with integrity, humility, and a dedication to hard work, continuous improvement, and attention to detail.

Contact: +1 608-238-2686

Address: 6200 Mineral Point Rd, Madison, WI 53705, United States

  1. Elevated Insurance

They are Waukesha, Wisconsin Independent Agents who are free to select the best carrier for their customers’ insurance needs.

When a customer suffers a loss, they work on their behalf to ensure that they receive fair, prompt payment and service.

Elevated Insurance represents a carefully chosen group of financially sound and reputable insurance companies.

As a result, they can provide their customers with the best coverage at the most competitive price.

Elevated Insurance was established in late 2016 under unusual circumstances. Jackson Bubolz, the company’s owner, had spent the previous four years sharing customer service, sales, and profitability strategies with small to mid-sized insurance agencies.

The primary goal was to provide more than a quote to agents’ clients, and the ideas were not well received by the industry.

Jackson was confident that he could provide a better service than the “Quote & Hope” mentality that seemed to be prevalent.

Because his primary goal in life is to assist others in achieving their goals, he left his high-profile and well-paid job to devote his full attention to serving his neighbors through a service that promotes self-growth and provides excellent insurance.

Contact: +1 262-424-0420

Address: 11225 W Bluemound Rd, Wauwatosa, WI 53226, United States

  1. MIB Health Insurance

MIB Health Insurance has spent over 35 years assisting clients in locating the innovative and personalized Health Insurance they require.

They understand how perplexing and complicated health insurance can be. MIB Health Insurance experts have spent over 35 years assisting clients in locating the customized Health Insurance they require.

Mike Dietz purchased Midwest Insurance Brokerage in June 2006 and rebranded his Employer Group Benefits business as MIB.

Over the years, he has worked in the ever-changing insurance industry, learning to navigate the overly complicated system in order to help his clients.

They provide lifetime service to their clients and have a client satisfaction rate of 99 percent. They grew their business by one satisfied client telling a friend or family member about their MIB experience. They prioritize their customers, whether it is an enrollment, claim, or benefit issue.

Contact: +1 920-731-2100

Address: 5733 W Packard St, Appleton, WI 54913, United States

  1. Insurance Brokers of Wisconsin

Brian Westrate, your local Insurance Brokers of WI agent in Altoona, WI, represents over 50 companies and is proud to be an independent agent.

Their goal is to work for their clients and ensure that they have the proper insurance for themselves, their families, and their businesses. There will be many changes in their clients’ lives, and they will be right there with them.

Wisconsin Insurance Brokers Altoona, founded in 1880, is located just north of Eau Claire.

It has the small-town charm and hospitality that attracts visitors and locals of all interests. Altoona has a variety of area attractions, events, and activities for visitors to enjoy while in Eau Claire.

Contact: +1 715-225-9107

Address: 3712 Spooner Ave, Altoona, WI 54720, United States

  1. Cottingham & Butler Insurance Services, Inc

Cottingham & Butler is the fifth largest privately held broker in the United States, the twenty-fifth largest insurance broker in the United States, and a recognized leader in providing innovative property & casualty and employee benefit insurance solutions.

The company is headquartered in Dubuque, Iowa, and employs over 1,000 people throughout the United States. Cottingham & Butler offers Property & Casualty Insurance, Casualty Claims Administration (TPA),Captives & Programs, Safety and Loss Control Consulting Services, Employee, Benefits Brokerage and Consulting, Compliance & HR Consulting Services, Benefit Claims Administration (TPA) Medical Management Services,Wellness and Disease Management Solutions, and Personal Insurance Services.

Contact: +1 608-467-5050

Address: 2323 Crossroads Dr #220, Madison, WI 53718, United States

  1. Insurance Services By Karen

They provide superior home, auto, and business insurance to their customers as Erie Insurance Agents.

Also, they give their customers confidence that they are well protected by providing award-winning service and low prices.

With 30 years of experience in the insurance industry, they have the knowledge and expertise to provide the best coverage at the most competitive price.

Some have advanced their education by obtaining the CPCU designation (Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter).

Working with clients to determine their insurance needs and de-mystify the insurance process are two of the most rewarding aspects of their job.

They have enjoyed learning about the many businesses in the Fox Valley and assisting them in controlling their insurance costs.

Contact: +1 920-252-2575

Address: 1429 Oregon St, Oshkosh, WI 54902, United States

  1. Jirschele Insurance

Jirschele Insurance, LLC was founded in 2008 with the goal of assisting people in overcoming the difficulties associated with understanding and selecting Medicare Health Plans, Health Insurance, and Life Insurance.

An independent approach enables them to offer competitive plans with multiple carriers across Wisconsin.

Clients are not charged for their time or services. For over ten years, their agents have served Oshkosh and the surrounding communities.

They are Wisconsin-licensed and independent, which means they represent multiple insurance companies, giving their clients greater purchasing power.

Clients pay only the agreed-upon premium set by the insurance company for services and time spent with them.

They are an independent agency dedicated to providing tailored Health Insurance Plans and Medicare Health Insurance Plans to Wisconsin businesses and individuals. They will serve their customers by having a local and personal presence.

Contact: +1 920-966-9500

Address: 923 S Main St Suite D, Oshkosh, WI 54902, United States

  1. Mitchell Insurance Agency

Mitchell Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency that is family owned and operated.

Jim Mitchell founded the agency from the ground up in Oshkosh, WI. Jim’s goal and commitment was and continues to be to provide his customers with the best service available locally, with choices and options tailored to each individual’s specific needs, at competitive rates.

Mitchell Insurance has been able to provide the small town, neighborly service and care that the people in their community desire and deserve by establishing their own independent agency.

They have over 30 companies, which greatly benefits their customers. This gives them many options and choices when tailoring a solution to clients’ needs while ensuring clients get the best price.

Contact: +1 920-233-0272

Address: 1924 S Washburn St, Oshkosh, WI 54902, United States

  1. Preferred Insurance Agency

Preferred Insurance Agency, based in La Crosse, Wisconsin, is an independent insurance agency that provides auto insurance, home insurance, flood insurance, business insurance, and life insurance.

They are permitted to operate in Wisconsin, Minnesota, and Iowa. Their agents are dedicated and take pride in providing excellent customer service to their clients.

Their reviews speak for themselves when it comes to customer service, with over 100 reviews on Google and Rocket Referrals.

Contact: +1 608-881-6566

Address: 401 King St, La Crosse, WI 54601, United States

Conclusion on the Insurance brokers in Wisconsin

The customer is relying on an expert to make an important financial decision. Customers want to know that they have an organization behind them that will take care of their needs, whether they are insuring their family, home, automobile, or other property.

That why they needs to get an Insurance Brokers that is capable of covering them when losses appears.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

  1. In Wisconsin, how many insurance companies are there?

There are 1,950 insurance companies.

In Wisconsin, there are over 1,950 insurance companies in the market, with over 330 of them based in the state.

  1. Is it less expensive to purchase insurance through a broker?

Neither a direct-to-consumer insurance company nor a broker is consistently less expensive than the other, but there are significant differences between them.

  1. In Wisconsin, how many independent insurance agencies are there?

With 423 independent agencies in Wisconsin, you can be confident that our recommended agents provide you with more options, better value, and are local.


Insurance brokers in New York

Top insurance brokers in Colorado

Insurance brokers in Massachusetts

Best insurance brokers in Hawaii

Top 10 Insurance Brokers in Wisconsin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to top